
Danielle Panabaker
Katie Lapp
Acting

Sherry Stringfield
Laura Mayfield-Bennett
Acting
![Willie Stratford]()
Willie Stratford
Theodore
Acting
![Jason Loughlin]()
Jason Loughlin
Benjamin Lapp
Acting

Sandra Elise Williams
Rebecca Lapp
Acting

Bill Oberst Jr.
Samuel Lapp
Acting
![Wyatt Lanier]()
Wyatt Lanier
Jacob Beiler
Acting

Burgess Jenkins
Bishop John Beiler
Acting
![Dalton Parrish]()
Dalton Parrish
Hickory John Beiler
Acting
![David Topp]()
David Topp
Daniel Fisher
Acting

Richard Fullerton
Ephram Yoder
Acting

Nancy Saunders
Ella Mae Zook
Acting

Rachel St. Gelais
Benjamin's Daughter
Acting
![Sarah E. Chambers]()
Sarah E. Chambers
Mary Stoltzfus
Acting
![Jimmy Hager]()
Jimmy Hager
Preacher Yoder
Acting
![David Forrester]()
David Forrester
Amish Elder
Acting

Robert C. Treveiler
Surgeon
Acting
![Stephen West-Rogers]()
Stephen West-Rogers
Trauma Nurse
Acting
![Lee Freeman]()
Lee Freeman
Nurse Rosie
Acting

Alexa Yeames
Young Laura
Acting
![Tim Holt]()
Tim Holt
Dylan Bennett
Acting
![Michele Lee]()
Michele Lee
Store Clerk
Acting

Lindsey Moser
Nurse (uncredited)
Acting