Lacey Chabert

Tess Harper

Acting

Brennan Elliott

Logan O'Connor

Acting

Barbara Niven

Aunt Candace

Acting

John Kapelos

Chief Chauncey O'Connor

Acting

Romaine Waite

Winston Sams

Acting

Lara Jean Chorostecki

Christina Blake

Acting

Alex Paxton-Beesley

Abby Miller

Acting

Kimberly J. Brown

Angela

Acting

Kyle Buchanan

Lyle Clark

Acting

Lindsay Owen Pierre

Emory Nelson

Acting

Genevieve Kang

Josephine

Acting

Janet Porter

Bethany

Acting

Kintaro Akiyama

Elliot

Acting

Will Shortz

Police Officer

Acting

Richard Ashton

Richards the Diamond Dealer

Acting

Jeffrey R. Smith

Baxter the Farmer

Acting

Josette Jorge

Librarian

Acting

Carrie Schiffler

Clerk

Acting

Racine Bebamikawe

Nurse Bethany

Acting

Jason Díaz

Clayton

Acting

Brenda Robins

Mildred Clark

Acting

Hannah Kanter

Student Worker

Acting

Bobby Daniels

Minister

Acting

Eryk Simon

Angela's Fiance / Groom

Acting