Pete Gardner
Bucky Bantershire
Acting
Marissa Jaret Winokur
Sweet Tooth
Acting
Ryder Robinson
Teddy Pinston
Acting
Lilah Collins
Polly Pinston
Acting
Lori Nasso
Mrs. Pinston
Acting
Gracie Moore
The Smile Judge
Acting
Paul Wong
The Smile Panelist
Acting
Sarah DeVincentis
Ginger
Acting
Sasha Ivanir
Margot
Acting
Isaac Amsterdam
Warren
Acting
Jesse Gillingham
Dinah (Smile Contestant)
Acting