Jennifer Connelly
Virginia
Acting
Emma Roberts
Jessie Tipton
Acting
Toby Jones
Max
Acting
Ed Harris
Sheriff Dick Tipton
Acting
Carrie Preston
Betty
Acting
Lucas Grabeel
Nervous Mormon
Acting
Yeardley Smith
Mrs. Whitaker
Acting
Amy Madigan
Mrs. Tipton
Acting
Anne Lockhart
Police Dispatch Operator (voice)
Acting
Alex Frost
Josh
Acting
Harrison Gilbertson
Emmett
Acting
Garrett Clayton
Mormon boy (as Gary Clayton)
Acting
Meighan Gerachis
Dawn
Acting
Paul Walter Hauser
Dale
Acting